High water haven
Stealing a march on the next Brisbane flood event, the renovation and downstairs fitout of Marion and Daniel’s Queenslander incorporates innovative flood-resilient design features.
In Brisbane’s great flood of 2011, first-time homeowners Marion Battig Franks and Daniel Franks watched the waters lap their driveway while their neighbour’s place flooded. After the waters receded, they helped clean up the sludge and disintegration left behind. Meanwhile, their friend of more than 20 years, architect James Davidson of JDA Co., was motivated by the devastation and waste to establish the Brisbane branch of Emergency Architects and develop new ways to build and retrofit more flood-resilient homes.
Traditional ‘Queenslander’ houses are elevated to capture breezes and handle floods, but the most common flood solution today is to raise them even higher. This approach can mean losing connection with the garden, and while potential new living spaces underneath can offer a cool retreat in summer and are great for people with mobility issues, they can still be a liability in a flood. Standard cavity walls, softwood framing, plasterboard linings and floor coverings to downstairs spaces soak up polluted water and disintegrate or harbour mould before they can dry out. James saw another way: “Just letting the floodwaters in and then letting them out again”. In flood-resilient home adaptations, polished concrete floors, single-skin walls, hardwood framing and thresholds flush with the floor enable inundated spaces to be simply hosed out and left to dry, allowing families to move back in within a few days. “This approach also avoids the huge waste generated by the need to strip and replace waterlogged traditional materials,” he says.
At what is now Marion and Daniel’s house, a neighbour remembers being able to moor his ‘tinny’ to their front verandah in the 1974 flood, and they know that one day it will happen again. Despite this, they love the high ceilings and solid timber construction of their 1920s Queenslander and its proximity to cycle paths and the train. The couple are committed to sustainable living and when it was time to extend for their family of five, they decided to stay and make their house more flood-resilient, with James’ help.
Daniel and Marion were accustomed to living in small homes in Brisbane and Europe and despite having three boys by the time they renovated, they increased the footprint by just 20 square metres. The upstairs was reconfigured only slightly, with the new living room pushing out toward the backyard to capture northern sun. Wide folding doors open onto a metre-wide balcony, efficiently converting the living room into an outdoor living space. Downstairs features bedrooms, bathroom, laundry, rumpus and a home office.
Demolition was minimal, with as much as possible recycled. Kitchen cabinets were reused for wardrobe and laundry storage and the appliances reinstated in the new kitchen. Demolished timbers and the original tin roof were converted into a characterful garden shed (“The only new thing is the roofing screws,” says Daniel) and other garden structures. The fall of the land was reworked to manage overland flow, with additional drainage and paved areas in salvaged and new bluestone paving, a lower embodied energy solution than concrete pavers.
Daniel and Marion were “committed to pushing the boundaries,” says James, experimenting with innovative sustainable materials and construction methods and thus contributing to JDA Co.’s industry-leading expertise in this area which will help others build back better in the future. Daniel lobbied local concrete suppliers Wagners for seven years to enable the use of a geopolymer concrete polished slab for the first time on a residential project, avoiding the high carbon emissions of standard Portland cement concrete. “It is made with a cementitious fly ash waste from coal-fired power and iron ore slag – also a waste product – mixed with a binder and aggregate to make a slab,” he explains. His email to the builder Tom Yabsley accepting all risk gave some reassurance and the concrete grinders learned on the job.
To achieve satisfactory energy ratings downstairs while still meeting the brief for flood resilience, James and Tom developed an insulated external wall free of cavities where water could become trapped. Expressed hardwood studs were used, with clear-finished hardwood shiplap cladding (set vertically to drain better) with sealed joins and 30-millimetre-thick closed-cell extruded polystyrene insulation behind. Internal walls are of waterproofed Hebel block, and sills are flush with the floor to allow easy hosing out after a flood. All walls downstairs are lined internally with fibre cement to give the appearance of familiar plasterboard, with hardwood trims. The goal with all of JDA Co.’s ‘flood houses’ is to encourage broad community uptake by ensuring they look no different to a normal home, and Marion and Daniel’s is no exception. “You have to put the architectural ego aside,’ says James. “It’s well built, it looks great. Nobody would know it’s doing a different job.”
Daniel and Marion didn’t want air conditioning so design for cross ventilation, aided by ceiling fans on muggy days, makes the house comfortable. “When you go downstairs in summer, it’s lovely and cool,” says Marion. The house is powered by grid-connected solar with a 10 kilowatt-hour battery sufficient to supply essential lights and the fridge in grid outages; as part of the flood resilience, upstairs and downstairs run on separate circuits so if downstairs becomes inundated the electricity can be shut off there and continue running upstairs.
The outcome of Daniel and Marion’s project is a reflection of the happy shared experience with builder and architect, with the family revelling in their reimagined, elegant, light-filled home. “It’s not all about utility,” says James, despite all the technical details and decisions. The home respects its heritage with old and new clearly expressed, and the interiors reflect Marion’s impeccable sense of style. The couple didn’t notice any significant extra cost for the flood-resilient design, which brings the added benefits of peace of mind and a 40 per cent reduction in their insurance premium.
Perth-based duo Dannielle Robertson and Sid Thoo describe how energy assessments can help identify the best places to spend your retrofit money.Read more
Uta Green explains the design process for her practice’s new studio in Hobart, including using iterative energy ratings to optimise the small building’s performance.Read more