Heating options in cold climate
Ask our experts: What are the heating options for a new house in the cold climate of Central Victoria.
The first thing I would say is that as you are in the process of building, you should build to require as little heating and cooling as possible. This means passive solar design and making best use of the block and house orientation. If this has not been a consideration in the house design then it would be good to consider it now as all forms of energy are increasing in cost and the less fuel you need, the better.
I would never use resistive panel heaters as a primary heat source. Their efficiency is only 100 per cent, so for every kilowatt-hour of heat required, you use that much electricity. There’s a lot of marketing hype around these types of panels, but they can only produce heat equivalent to the electrical input.
A good quality heat pump will use a third of what resistive heating does for the same heat production, even in cold areas. As you don’t like the feel of the flowing air, then a heat pump hydronic system might be your best option. The efficiency (actually known as the coefficient of performance) will be two to three, ie an effective efficiency two to three times that of resistive heating if using an air-sourced heat pump system, although some heat pumps perform better than others at low temperatures.
For a ground sourced heat pump you could see a coefficient of performance (CoP) of up to five. The advantage of using a heat pump system is that you are also not locked into one source of energy. Should you get tired of paying too much for electricity, you can install solar photovoltaic panels to provide some or all of the heat pump’s needs.
You might also want to look at a solar hydronic system that uses a heat pump as a backup for cloudy days. Such a system would have the lowest running cost as some of the input would be free from the solar collectors.
I wouldn’t consider a gas powered system as it will use a lot of gas and the only reasonably
economical option would be to install a large tank that is refilled by tanker truck. Forty-five
kilogram bottles will need to be swapped too often and will simply cost too much. – Lance Turner, Renew technial editor
You might also like
As we head into the colder months, thoughts turn to staying warm. What’s the best electric heating system for you?Read more
There's a lot to learn from this highly insulated and well-sealed renovation in Melbourne, not least how a heat pump is providing both hydronic heating and hot water. Cameron Munro explains the house's modelling-led upgrades and the tweaks made along the way.Read more